Yes, I thought that, too...
You look at the stats, and the match is a foregone conclusion
ranking: 3 vs. 31
GS titles : 16 vs 1
carreer titles : 73 vs. 30
YTD match record : 22/2 vs. 5/5
H2H : 21 - 2 last time Roddick won, was way back in '08...
And he goes and beats Fed, only to go down 7-5, 6-0 against Monaco in the next match.....
For a Fed fan, it's maddening.
But have to admit, Roddick played really well in that 3rd set, while Fed obliged him with some spotty play, and that's all it took.