Interesting to see that this poll is acually close between these 2 guys!
Maybe because a lot of us have 'fed-goggles' on, as most of the board are fed-fans, so we're voting against Nadal. As for the others, none of them have yet shown consistency of the same level as Nadal and Djokovic.
I suppose. For Murray, he needs to stop getting injured.
Yep, that's his consistency issue, although it could relate to general fitness. For instance, in his 3 masters semi-finals, aainst Gasquet and Djokovic twice, he hasn't shown up in any of them, once tired, twice injured. For the others (Monfils, Gasquet, Berdych, Baghdatis) the problems are mental.